A Few Thoughts on Natural Patterns

A 2019 study from Shanghai Jiao Tong University’s School of Design in China examined an often-encountered yet relatively under-examined form of ornamentation: decorative wallpaper (Fu, Zhang, & Lin, 2019). The researchers examined two properties: regularity (the orderly repetition of motifs) and semantic decodability (how readily those motifs convey recognizable meaning). Using the Implicit Association Test, which assesses relative associations through differences in classification response times, they found evidence of implicit preferences for regular over random patterns and realistic over abstract ones. The authors interpreted their findings as consistent with enhanced processing fluency associated with translational symmetry and recognizable motifs. And while I would not stretch such a narrow study to make unwarranted general assumptions about the grand landscape of the “art experience,” it offers a useful starting point for considering how repetition and recognizable forms—including those encountered in nature—may contribute to the appeal of patterns that find their way onto our canvases.

It should be noted here that while patterns can be described as discernible regularities, natural patterns are often set apart as those discernible regularities that occur in nature, independent of human artifice. In certain contexts, these patterns can be usefully contrasted with what some describe as “man-made” patterns, such as those deliberately constructed in design and language. However, in many cases, clear divisions between these categories can blur or even disappear. One such case is the arts.

Symmetries, spirals, tessellations, fractals, waves, foams, meanders, stripes, and other natural patterns have been finding their way into artistic endeavors throughout human history. This should come as no surprise, as what we call visual art is a product of unrelenting pattern-seekers (or more accurately, pattern generators) who have evolved to find visible regularities in the environment to inform the countless prediction tasks that support our survival and reproduction. As such, perceiving such regularities can also elicit what we might describe as an aesthetic response.

A number of prehistoric figures were brought to public attention in 1949 at the Grotta del Genovese, on the northwest side of Levanzo Island. This cave contains engravings dating to the late Palaeolithic and paintings attributed to the later Neolithic period.

Today, many brilliant minds continue to investigate why specific patterns trigger the emotionally charged responses they do (Ulrich, 1983; Spehar et al., 2003). And while there do appear to be many compelling ideas about why this or that pattern in nature may elicit a positive aesthetic response, I would argue that, in most cases, processing fluency does much of the heavy lifting. According to the processing fluency theory, the more fluently a perceiver can process an object, the more positive his or her aesthetic response. This concept is also presented in the study I mentioned earlier on decorative patterns: “Fluent processing produces a positive affective response, which is often attributed to subjective preference (Reber, Schwarz, et al., 2004). In this theory account, processing fluency is considered to be comprised of perceptual fluency and conceptual fluency, with the former influenced by low-level processes related to the forms of stimuli, and the latter influenced by high-level variables such as semantic guidance or semantic predictability (Reber, Wurtz, & Zimmermann, 2004).”

For example, it is well established that in many contexts, humans strongly prefer symmetrical over asymmetrical or random shapes (Jacobsen & Höfel, 2002; Reber, Schwarz, & Winkielman, 2004). Many argue that preferences for symmetry, particularly in faces and potential mates, reflect its proposed role as a cue to health or genetic quality (Grammer & Thornhill, 1994; Jones et al., 2001; Møller & Thornhill, 1998). However, others point to studies of the associations between health and symmetry to argue otherwise (Pound et al., 2014). In either case, this discernible regularity—common in biological forms—can be detected with great ease, although its perceptual salience depends on factors including position and orientation (Wenderoth, 1994).

Fractals (or approximations of them), often characterized by self-similarity across scales, are also found throughout nature. They appear in the forms of trees, clouds, and coastlines, where self-similarity is (again) approximate or statistical and extends over a limited range of scales. The hypothesis that our visual systems have adapted to process certain fractal characteristics common in natural scenery efficiently has been termed fractal fluency (Taylor & Spehar, 2016).

I would argue that our fluency with natural patterns allows the aesthetic influence (at least in part) to survive translation through “man-made” pattern processes, such as mathematical models or representational efforts by skilled creatives. In fact, existing research has found comparable patterns of aesthetic preference across natural, mathematically generated, and artistic fractal images (Spehar et al., 2003). A simple visit to just about any museum today can be a journey through the history of art’s use of these visual regularities. From Georgia O’Keeffe’s bold, colorful expressions of symmetrical subjects to Bierstadt’s lavish landscapes riddled with virtuoso fractal-like foliage, adept creatives have long used natural patterns to their aesthetic advantage.

Stunning examples of representational paintings featuring natural patterns by California artist Emma Hirst. From left: Ripening, 7×5″, Burro’s Tail, 7×5″, and Awakening, 7×5″. All are oil on panel.

And while we do indeed find many “successes” in translating natural patterns across the broad landscape of the visual arts, there are also a good number of proposed applications that I would unapologetically describe as unfounded, if not downright nonsensical. These applications need not communicate or translate the perceptible, discernible regularity of a natural pattern subject to fluent processing, but instead attempt to translate some “extracted” component of the pattern’s structure or extract some component of a translation. The mathematical correspondences invoked to justify these convoluted transformations DO NOT demonstrate that they yield comparable aesthetic influence. Such transformations are often used in pictorial composition, serving as compositional armatures or design mechanisms.

Two specific cases that continue to find support among contemporary creatives are the Golden Ratio/Spiral and Dynamic Symmetry. In both cases, some proponents claim that elements can be extracted from a mathematical translation of a natural pattern while retaining the original pattern’s aesthetic impact. Additionally, these proponents argue that the new extraction can infuse an entirely new context with some of the source’s aesthetic potential. Unfortunately, the aesthetic response found in perceiving the original pattern cannot be assumed to apply equally to all conceivable aspects of the pattern, let alone survive in extracts or translations.

The correspondence between the arrangement of sunflower florets and pinecone spirals and the Fibonacci sequence is often put forward as evidence for claims of aesthetic advantage based on Dynamic Symmetry (DS) and the use of the Golden Ratio (GR). The strategies for reassigning the aesthetic impact found with these natural patterns, according to proponents of this argument, require the extraction of a mathematical sequence from the observed pattern, followed by a translation into a geometric armature that is supposedly capable of, via alignment, imbuing a new context with the aesthetic potential inherent to the original pattern.

Furthermore, such translation-component extraction-reassignment strategies seem to overlook the role of the original pattern’s perceptual characteristics in the aesthetic responses it elicits. To the extent that a transformation removes the characteristics responsible for a particular response, that response cannot be assumed to survive merely because an abstract mathematical relationship remains. If numerical correspondence alone were sufficient to establish such a transfer, one could claim comparable effects for other extractions taken from descriptions of a stimulus. For example, I could write a song about “12, 22, and 11” and claim that it provides pleasure comparable to that experienced when consuming sugar. The white stuff we know as table sugar is sucrose, a molecule composed of 12 carbon atoms, 22 hydrogen atoms, and 11 oxygen atoms (C₁₂H₂₂O₁₁). As should be fairly obvious, the numerical correspondence would not justify that claim.

Canadian-born American artist and author Jay Hambidge proposed Dynamic Symmetry in the 1920s, claiming that patterns found in growing plants and human figures formed “the basic principles underlying the greatest art so far produced in the world.” Hambidge developed a system of geometric constructions and proportions that he associated with natural forms and historical art. The critical question is whether those associations substantiate the aesthetic superiority he attributed to the system. Early critics challenged both his analyses and his conclusions. Fortunately, others spotted the fatal errors in his reasoning fairly quickly after he published. Author Edwin M. Blake stated in his 1921 Dynamic Symmetry—A Criticism (in The Art Bulletin, volume 3, issue 3, pages 107–127), “The claim that Dynamic Symmetry in any way expresses the essentials of plant and animal forms is without rational foundation…The attempt to base differences of artistic quality on the distinction between rational and irrational quantities, whether of length or area, is bound to fail — the eye is powerless to make the distinction.” In other words, Mr. Hambidge’s unsubstantiated claims aside, exact mathematical irrationality cannot itself establish a perceptible aesthetic advantage over a visually indistinguishable rational approximation.

It is at this point in most of my lectures or discussions on this topic (when I mention that we cannot find aesthetic responses to the imperceptible) that someone inevitably brings up some idea of “subliminal detection/perception/stimulation.” They suggest that perhaps some subliminal influence arises from the seemingly undetectable aspects extracted from the natural patterns on which they are based. Some go even further and attempt to substantiate this idea by citing the all-too-famous “Vicary Experiment,” in which market consultant James Vicary claimed he could increase sales of Coca-Cola and popcorn by exposing audiences to marketing messages for .003 seconds (well below the perceptual threshold). Unfortunately for proponents of subliminal messaging who continue to tout this tale, the fact of the matter is that it never happened. After failed attempts to recreate the results of his “study,” Mr. Vicary confessed, when pressed, that he had falsified the results. Worse yet, in a 1962 interview with Advertising Age, Vicary revealed that the entire “study” was a hoax. Now, this is not to say that subliminal detection/perception/stimulation in the context of this article is complete nonsense. Much ongoing research in this area is being conducted with great care. However, the effects demonstrated seem extremely transient and bear little to no resemblance to the general concept promoted in popular culture.

All in all, I expect the walls of our museums, galleries, homes, and workplaces to continue to host countless perceptible references to and representations of natural patterns. Whether through processing fluency, proposed adaptations associated with mate or habitat selection, or anything else that might appeal to the great grey and white prediction machine, these patterns remain a well-established fundamental component of the visual arts. So the next time you find yourself gazing into a canvas that gives you great pleasure, look for a natural pattern that may be contributing to the experience.

I would like to offer a special thank-you to colleagues Maneesh Yadav and Michael Carson for their help and advice on this article. I am very grateful for their time, expertise, and generosity.